MLB The Show 26: How to Build the Best Pitching Staff for Your Team

Building a strong pitching staff in MLB The Show 26 is not about collecting the highest overall cards. It’s about building a group that covers different matchups, different pitch speeds, and different player habits online. Most games are decided by pitching more than hitting, especially once you face players who can time fastballs consistently.

Below is a practical way to build a staff that wins games, based on what actually works in Ranked, Events, and even offline grinding.

What Should You Look for in a Starting Pitcher?

A good starter in MLB The Show 26 needs three things: usable pitch mix, strong per-9s, and an easy-to-control delivery.

The pitch mix matters more than overall rating. A starter with a 4-seam, sinker, slider, and changeup will usually play better than a starter with five average pitches that don’t tunnel well. In online games, the sinker is still one of the most important pitches because it forces weak contact if located properly.

The per-9 stats matter because they affect how forgiving your pitcher is. Higher H/9 and K/9 reduces the size of the opponent’s PCI and increases weak contact. BB/9 affects how easy it is to hit perfect pinpoint inputs and how much the ball “leaks” if you miss. If you use pinpoint, BB/9 becomes noticeable quickly.

Also, don’t ignore stamina. If you want your starter to consistently go 6–8 innings, you need a pitcher who can hold energy and confidence without collapsing after 70 pitches.

How Many Different Pitch Types Should Your Rotation Have?

The best rotation isn’t five similar right-handed power pitchers. You want variety.

A strong rotation usually includes:

At least one lefty

At least one sinker/cutter pitcher

At least one high-velocity four-seam pitcher

At least one pitcher with a strong offspeed (circle change, screwball, or splitter)

At least one pitcher with a funky delivery or deceptive release

The goal is to prevent opponents from getting comfortable. Many players hit better once they’ve seen the same fastball speed and break patterns for multiple games.

If you run three starters with similar pitch mixes (4-seam, slider, changeup), good hitters will adjust fast.

Should You Prioritize Velocity or Control?

Most players should prioritize control first, then velocity.

Velocity is useful, but velocity alone doesn’t win games. A 102 mph fastball down the middle is still getting hit. Control helps you hit corners, set up strikeouts, and avoid free baserunners. In MLB The Show 26, walk-heavy innings usually lead to multi-run damage.

That said, elite velocity becomes more important once you face higher-level opponents. In Hall of Fame and Legend difficulty games, a pitcher who tops out at 95 can feel easier to time, especially if their breaking pitches aren’t sharp.

A balanced staff usually has:

One or two flamethrowers

Two control-focused starters with good movement

One wildcard starter who plays differently than the rest

Which Pitch Mixes Perform Best Online?

Some pitch mixes consistently play better because they tunnel well and create weak contact.

The most effective mixes usually include:

Sinker + cutter combo

Slider + circle change combo

4-seam up + hard breaking ball down (slider or curve)

A sinker/cutter pitcher is strong because both pitches look similar out of the hand but break in different directions. A lot of hitters swing early thinking it’s a sinker, only to roll over a cutter.

A circle change is also one of the best pitches in the game because it kills timing without needing extreme break. If you can throw it low and away consistently, it forces weak swings.

Try to avoid pitchers with multiple slow looping pitches (like curveball + sweeping curve + changeup). Good players can sit on one speed and react.

How Important Are Pitching Attributes Like H/9 and K/9?

They matter more than most players admit.

In MLB The Show 26, H/9 is one of the biggest “hidden” advantages. It reduces how easily your opponent squares up the ball. K/9 makes strikeouts easier because it affects the PCI and foul ball rates.

BB/9 matters for consistency. Even if you’re good at pinpoint, low BB/9 pitchers tend to miss spots more often. That can turn a well-called pitch into a mistake pitch.

Clutch also matters in tight situations. Some pitchers feel fine early, then suddenly start giving up hits with runners on. Clutch is part of that.

If you’re choosing between two starters, and one has clearly better H/9 and BB/9, that pitcher is usually the better competitive choice even if their overall is lower.

How Do You Build a Bullpen That Actually Holds Leads?

A good bullpen needs roles, not just high overalls.

Most players lose leads because they bring in relievers that don’t match the situation. Your bullpen should include:

At least one hard-throwing righty

At least one hard-throwing lefty

One sinker/slider reliever for ground balls

One reliever with a strong changeup or splitter

One long reliever for extra innings or early starter exits

The best bullpen arms usually have either elite velocity or elite movement, plus good control. Relief pitchers with low stamina are fine as long as you use them for one inning.

Also, don’t overload your bullpen with closers. Some closers have great attributes but predictable pitch mixes. You need at least one “awkward” reliever who feels uncomfortable to face.

Should You Carry Multiple Left-Handed Relievers?

Yes, but not too many.

Two lefties is usually the sweet spot. One should be a power lefty (fastball/slider type). The other can be a finesse lefty with a changeup or sweeping breaking ball.

If you carry three or four lefties, you’ll run into games where your opponent stacks right-handed hitters and you’re forced into bad matchups. Lefty specialists can be strong, but only if they can also get righties out.

A lefty reliever without a good pitch to attack right-handers becomes easy to sit on.

What’s the Best Way to Choose Your Closer?

Your closer should be your most reliable pitcher, not necessarily your highest rated.

Look for:

High control and BB/9

A pitch mix that can miss bats (slider, cutter, splitter)

A delivery you personally locate well with

High clutch

A closer that you can’t command is a liability. Even if they throw 102, you’ll eventually miss a spot and give up a late homer.

Also, avoid closers with slow windups if you struggle with runners stealing bases. Online players will take extra bases if they see a slow delivery.

How Do You Stop Opponents From Sitting on Your Fastball?

This is where most players fail. They throw too many fastballs early and become predictable.

To stop this, you need to use fastballs as setup pitches, not default pitches. A good approach is:

Throw offspeed early in counts sometimes

Use inside sinkers to jam hitters

Change eye level every inning

Avoid repeating the same pattern twice

If you always go fastball up on 0-0, your opponent will start swinging immediately. Mix in first-pitch sliders or changeups to steal strikes and break timing.

Also, remember that many players struggle more with mid-speed pitches than pure speed. A cutter at 92–95 can be harder to hit than a 101 mph fastball, because it ruins timing without looking obvious.

How Should You Spend Resources on Pitchers?

Most competitive players invest in pitching first because it gives consistent results.

If you have limited stubs, prioritize:

One ace starter you trust

Two elite bullpen arms

One lefty starter or lefty reliever depending on your mode

After that, fill the rotation with pitchers that match your style. If you locate well, control pitchers play better. If you rely on strikeouts, velocity and break matter more.

Some players search markets and upgrades constantly, especially if they want MLB 26 stubs instant delivery, but even then the smarter move is buying pitchers that actually fit your gameplay instead of chasing the newest card.

How Do You Know If a Pitcher Is Actually Good for You?

The best way is to test them in real games, not just look at ratings.

A pitcher is “good” if:

You consistently hit corners with them

Their pitches get weak contact even when the opponent makes contact

Their release point feels comfortable

You can strike out good hitters without relying on luck

Some pitchers with great attributes still get hit because their delivery is easy to read. Other pitchers with lower overalls dominate because the ball comes out weird or the pitches tunnel well.

If you’re winning consistently with a pitcher, keep them. Don’t replace them just because a new card dropped.

What’s a Simple Pitching Staff Setup That Works for Most Players?

A reliable staff for most players looks like this:

Rotation

One elite right-handed ace with sinker/cutter

One hard-throwing strikeout pitcher

One lefty with a good changeup

One control pitcher with strong per-9s

One wildcard pitcher with an unusual delivery

Bullpen

Two righty power arms

Two righty control/ground ball arms

Two lefties (one power, one finesse)

One flexible long reliever

This setup covers most situations without forcing you into predictable matchups.

Final Advice: Don’t Build a Staff That All Feels the Same

A lot of players accidentally build a pitching staff where every pitcher throws the same speeds and breaks. That’s when opponents start hitting everything by the 5th inning.

If your staff gives hitters different timing windows, different pitch shapes, and different release points, you’ll win more games even without perfect execution.

In MLB The Show 26, pitching is about being difficult to read. The best staff isn’t the one with the highest overalls. It’s the one that keeps your opponent uncomfortable for nine innings.

---

---